Hospital authorities initiate examination, question authenticity of earlier report
Asif Iqbal
Srinagar, Nov 18 (GNS): A parent has raised concerns over the accuracy of laboratory testing at Government Medical College (GMC) Handwara, alleging that two blood group tests conducted on his child, months apart, allegedly yielded different results.
The parent, identifying himself as Adil Sultan, told GNS that his four-year-old child, who was diagnosed with tonsillitis, was first examined at GMC Handwara in July 2026, when doctors advised several investigations, including blood group identification, ahead of a proposed surgical procedure.
Adil claimed that the laboratory report issued at the time identified the child’s blood group as O Negative (O-). “The finding surprised us because, to the best of our knowledge, nobody in our family has this blood group,” he said.
He said the family was subsequently assigned a date for surgery but had to seek its postponement due to domestic circumstances. The hospital administration, he said, accommodated the request and advised them to return on another date.
“On November 12, when we revisited the hospital, we were asked to repeat the investigations as considerable time had passed since the earlier tests. However, the fresh report identified the child’s blood group as AB Positive (AB+),” Adil alleged.
He further claimed that upon bringing the apparent discrepancy to the attention of the laboratory technician, the report was taken back and the sample retested to rule out any possibility of error. “Even the repeat test returned AB+,” he said.
Questioning the implications of the alleged discrepancy, Adil said, “Had my child required blood during surgery, which blood group would have been transfused? What kind of system and laboratory is this?”
“This is not an ordinary mistake. It is an extremely serious matter that could put a patient’s life at risk,” he said, demanding a high-level investigation into the alleged laboratory error and the functioning of the institution.
Expressing apprehension that other patients could also have received inaccurate reports, he said, “Only God knows how many unsuspecting patients may have been affected by such inaccurate reporting.” He sought accountability and appropriate action against those found responsible for the alleged negligence.
Meanwhile, responding to GNS, Medical Superintendent GMC Handwara, Dr Aijaz Ahmad Bhat, said he had taken up the matter with the Head of the Department of Biochemistry.
“The HOD informed me that they have checked the records and, as per the available records, the blood group identification is AB+,” Dr Bhat said.
When informed that the parent had shared copies of the purported reports indicating a different blood group in the earlier test, the Medical Superintendent acknowledged the need for further examination.
“This is a matter that warrants investigation. If this is indeed the case, it requires action, as such an error can have far-reaching consequences for a patient,” he said.
Dr Bhat, however, questioned the parent’s decision to raise the issue on social media without first approaching the hospital administration, saying the family should have brought the matter to the authorities so that an investigation could have been initiated.
“Let the parent approach us. We will look into the matter, establish the facts and take necessary action accordingly,” he said.
Principal GMC Handwara, Khursheed Ahmad Wani, also told GNS that the matter was being examined in consultation with the HOD Biochemistry, Medical Superintendent and other concerned officials.
“The two reports are several months apart. We suspect that one of them is from outside. The earlier report appears highly unreliable, as there seem to be discrepancies in the MRD numbers and dates,” Wani said.
He maintained that the aggrieved parent should have approached the hospital administration with the reports so that their authenticity could be verified.
“Let the father or attendant come to us with a representation. If there is any negligence on the part of the hospital, we will take necessary action, if warranted,” the Principal said. (GNS)