Judge Parvaiz Iqbal Says Prosecution Failed To Establish Foundational Facts; Calls Investigation A Textbook Example Of Serious Investigative Failures
Court Directs NCB To Fix Responsibility Of Officers; Questions Unauthorised Transfer Of Case From Police To NCB
JAMMU, NOVEMBER 18 (KNC): In a significant judgment in a major narcotics trafficking case involving the seizure of 50.300 kilograms of heroin, the Court of Special Judge (NDPS Cases), Jammu, on Wednesday acquitted all three accused, holding that the prosecution had failed to establish their guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
The judgment was delivered by Special Judge Parvaiz Iqbal in NCB Crime No. 10/2018, titled Union of India through Narcotics Control Bureau versus Gurjit Singh and Others, observing that serious investigative lapses, procedural violations, contradictions in prosecution evidence and failure to establish essential facts had severely weakened the prosecution’s case.
The accused acquitted in the case are Gurjit Singh, son of Balbir Singh, resident of Digiana Ashram, Jammu; Ravi Kumar, son of Romesh Kumar, resident of Raipur Satwari, Jammu; and Ravinder Singh, son of Hazara Singh, resident of Chatha Farm, Jammu.
The court held them not guilty of offences under Sections 8, 21, 29 and 60 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985, and dismissed the prosecution complaint for failure to prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt.
50.300 KG HEROIN RECOVERED FROM TRUCK IN AUGUST 2018
According to the prosecution, the case originated on August 6, 2018, following secret information regarding transportation of a large consignment of heroin in truck bearing registration number JK02AD-3965.
The vehicle was intercepted at Rajiv Nagar Chowk, Narwal, Jammu, during a joint operation involving Jammu and Kashmir Police and the Narcotics Control Bureau.
The truck was being driven by Gurjit Singh, while Ravi Kumar was travelling as its conductor.
During the proceedings, both occupants were served notices under Section 50 of the NDPS Act and their personal searches were conducted in the presence of an Executive Magistrate. No narcotic substance was recovered from their personal possession.
The prosecution alleged that the accused disclosed the presence of heroin concealed inside a specially constructed false cavity in the truck.
Following the movement of a crowd at the interception site, the vehicle was shifted to Police Post Bathindi, where the loaded scrap was removed and 51 packets of suspected narcotics were recovered from the concealed compartment.
The recovered substance tested positive for heroin. Its gross weight, including packing material, was recorded as 52.523 kilograms, while the net quantity was determined to be 50.300 kilograms.
NCB TAKES OVER INVESTIGATION; THREE ACCUSED CHARGED
Following the recovery, the investigation was taken over by the NCB, Jammu.
The recovered substance was divided into five lots, marked A, B, C, D and E. Ten representative samples, each weighing five grams, were drawn and sealed for chemical examination.
The chemical examination reports subsequently confirmed the presence of Diacetyl Morphine (heroin) in the samples.
The NCB initially proceeded against Gurjit Singh and Ravi Kumar. Ravinder Singh was subsequently implicated on the basis of the investigation concerning alleged communications and meetings with Gurjit Singh during his imprisonment at Central Jail Kot Bhalwal.
The trial against the first two accused commenced after charges were framed on May 3, 2019. Ravinder Singh was initially discharged, but the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh set aside the discharge order on July 3, 2024. Charges against him were subsequently framed on January 10, 2025.
COURT FINDS SERIOUS PROCEDURAL AND INVESTIGATIVE LAPSES
While examining the prosecution evidence, Special Judge Parvaiz Iqbal identified several serious deficiencies in the investigation and handling of the seized contraband.
The court observed that the investigation had been transferred from the police to the NCB without the requisite approval from the competent government authorities.
The judgment noted that although FIR No. 212/2018 had been registered at Police Station Bahu Fort, the SHO had handed over the investigation to the NCB without an order from the State Government, Central Government or any constitutional court.
The court further expressed concern that the original FIR had reportedly remained open for years, with no proper accountability regarding its subsequent progress.
SECTION 52-A COMPLIANCE AND SAMPLING PROCEDURE QUESTIONED
One of the significant issues highlighted in the judgment concerned compliance with Section 52-A of the NDPS Act.
The court observed that the seized contraband and representative samples had not been properly produced and identified during the trial.
It also questioned the manner in which the NCB handled the subsequent proceedings concerning inventory, certification and sampling before the Magistrate.
The judgment noted that documents relating to Section 52-A proceedings were not made part of the original complaint, and the investigating officer had failed to disclose these proceedings during his testimony.
The court further highlighted contradictions regarding the sampling process, including the preparation of an initial homogeneous mixture from 51 packets and the subsequent division of the substance into five lots for drawing representative samples.
CHAIN OF CUSTODY OF SEIZED HEROIN ALSO UNDER CLOUD
The court also took serious note of the handling and custody of the seized contraband.
It observed that the investigating officer, Koushal Kumar, had retained the seized substance and samples in his possession from August 6 to August 8, 2018, instead of depositing them immediately in the NCB Malkhana.
According to the judgment, the defence had raised substantial objections regarding the sanctity of the samples and the possibility of the chain of custody being compromised.
The court found substance in the defence objections and observed that the investigating officer was not justified in retaining the seized material and samples in his personal custody.
FAILURE TO ASSOCIATE INDEPENDENT WITNESSES
Another major deficiency identified by the court was the failure of the investigating agencies to associate independent civilian witnesses despite the presence of several officials and members of the public at the relevant locations.
The judgment noted that senior police officers, including the SDPO and SP City South, the DIG, Tehsildar and other civilians were reportedly present during the proceedings.
However, the prosecution failed to explain why these persons were not associated as witnesses.
The court observed that there was no case presented by the prosecution that efforts had been made to involve civilians but they had refused to participate.
CONTRADICTIONS IN STATEMENTS OF POLICE AND NCB OFFICERS
The judgment also highlighted substantial inconsistencies in the testimonies of prosecution witnesses regarding the arrival of the NCB team, the timing of the operation and the respective roles played by police and NCB officials.
The court noted discrepancies concerning when the NCB team reached the interception point and who had actually conducted the initial proceedings.
It further questioned the absence of proper documentation regarding the transfer of custody of the accused, the seized material and the vehicle from the police to the NCB.
The court also observed that the recovery and seizure documentation contained deficiencies and that several important aspects of the operation had not been properly recorded.
COURT QUESTIONS ROLE OF INVESTIGATING OFFICER C.S. RATHORE
The court made particularly serious observations regarding the investigation conducted by NCB officer C.S. Rathore, who was assigned the case on August 10, 2018.
The judgment pointed out that there was a delay of approximately four days in assigning a regular investigating officer after the NCB took over the matter.
It also noted that the investigating officer had failed to properly investigate the forward and backward linkages of the alleged narcotics consignment.
The court questioned the failure to establish the source of the heroin, its intended destination and whether any possible terror-related angle had been investigated.
It further described the conduct of PW-10 C.S. Rathore as seriously questionable and made adverse observations regarding his testimony about Section 52-A proceedings.
COURT SAYS PROSECUTION FAILED TO ESTABLISH FOUNDATIONAL FACTS
In its assessment of the evidence, the court reiterated that the initial burden of establishing the foundational facts rests with the prosecution.
Only after those foundational facts are established can the statutory presumptions under Sections 35 and 54 of the NDPS Act operate against the accused.
After examining the evidence and the shortcomings highlighted by the defence, the court concluded that the prosecution had miserably failed to establish the necessary foundational facts.
Consequently, there was no question of shifting the burden of proof onto the accused under the relevant provisions of the NDPS Act.
JUDGE CALLS INVESTIGATION A TEXTBOOK EXAMPLE OF FAILURE
In a strongly worded observation, Special Judge Parvaiz Iqbal stated that the investigation in the case, which had earned a reward of Rs 17 lakh for the police and NCB investigating teams, had been conducted with serious lapses and a lack of accountability.
The court observed that the prosecution’s case had collapsed because of the mistakes committed by its own investigating officers.
It held that both the police and NCB shared responsibility for the failure of the prosecution.
The court also stressed that the NCB must identify and fix responsibility on officers whose conduct and investigative shortcomings contributed to the failure of the case.
The judgment emphasised that seizure of contraband is only the beginning of an NDPS investigation and that proper investigation, legal compliance, preservation of evidence and accountability are essential for securing convictions.
ALL THREE ACCUSED ACQUITTED; PROSECUTION COMPLAINT DISMISSED
In the operative portion of the judgment, the court declared all three accused not guilty of offences under Sections 8, 21, 29 and 60 of the NDPS Act and acquitted them.
The prosecution complaint was accordingly dismissed for failure to establish their guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
The court further recorded that the seized contraband had already been destroyed in 2021 following proceedings under Section 52-A of the NDPS Act.
It directed that the other seized articles, including the truck, be released in favour of their rightful claimants.
The judgment was pronounced on November 18, 2026, in the virtual presence of the accused lodged at District Jail Anantnag and Central Jail Kot Bhalwal, Jammu, and in the physical presence of the Special Public Prosecutor and the defence counsel.
The case was argued by Special Public Prosecutor Ajay Singh Manhas on behalf of the NCB, while Advocate Prince Khanna represented the accused.
The judgment was pronounced by Special Judge Parvaiz Iqbal, NDPS Court, Jammu, on November 18, 2026.(KNC)